- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
Spatial clustering of measles cases during endemic (1998–2002) and epidemic (2010) periods in Lusaka, Zambia
BMC Infectious Diseasesvolume 15, Article number: 121 (2015)
Measles cases may cluster in densely populated urban centers in sub-Saharan Africa as susceptible individuals share spatially dependent risk factors and may cluster among human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected children despite high vaccination coverage.
Children hospitalized with measles at the University Teaching Hospital (UTH) in Lusaka, Zambia were enrolled in the study. The township of residence was recorded on the questionnaire and mapped; SaTScan software was used for cluster detection. A spatial-temporal scan statistic was used to investigate clustering of measles in children hospitalized during an endemic period (1998 to 2002) and during the 2010 measles outbreak in Lusaka, Zambia.
Three sequential and spatially contiguous clusters of measles cases were identified during the 2010 outbreak but no clustering among HIV-infected children was identified. In contrast, a space-time cluster among HIV-infected children was identified during the endemic period. This cluster occurred prior to the introduction of intensive measles control efforts and during a period between seasonal peaks in measles incidence.
Prediction and early identification of spatial clusters of measles will be critical to achieving measles elimination. HIV infection may contribute to spatial clustering of measles cases in some epidemiological settings.
Despite a 74% decline in global measles deaths between 2000 and 2010 [1,2], measles remains a significant cause of mortality in children younger than five years of age. In the African region, there were an estimated 139300 measles deaths in 2010 . The Measles and Rubella Initiative developed a joint strategic plan to reduce measles deaths by strengthening routine immunization, providing a second dose of measles vaccine through supplemental immunization activities (SIAs) in the form of mass vaccination campaigns, enhanced surveillance with laboratory confirmation of suspected cases, and appropriate case management . However, measles elimination remains challenging in sub-Saharan Africa where obstacles to achieving high coverage with two doses of measles vaccine include weak routine immunization services, high force of infection in densely populated urban settings, conflict and civil unrest, and limited financial resources [4,5].
Infectious diseases such as measles tend to cluster geographically where susceptible individuals reside in close proximity. As a result, spatial analyses are important to detect and predict the spatial and temporal patterns of infectious diseases [6-9]. For pathogens directly transmitted from person-to-person, such as measles virus, disease outbreaks may cluster in urban areas where the susceptible population is large and dense . High vaccination coverage may interrupt these processes over large geographical areas .
Potentially impacting the spatial clustering of measles are regions of high human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) prevalence, particularly in urban areas. Recent measles outbreaks in South Africa were reported to be associated with HIV infection . There are several reasons HIV-infected children may play a role in maintaining measles virus transmission [12-15]. HIV-infected mothers may have defective transfer of IgG antibody across the placenta, resulting in lower levels of protective antibodies in the infant and enlarging the period of susceptibility to measles virus infection prior to routine immunization [16,17]. HIV-infected children may not have an adequate primary response to measles immunization and may lose immunity with progressive immunosuppression, thus remaining susceptible to measles virus despite immunization , with immunity not restored by antiretroviral therapy . Children with defective cell-mediated immunity may not develop the characteristic measles rash so infection may go unrecognized [18,20]. And HIV-infected children may have prolonged shedding of measles virus increasing the period of infectivity and the spread of measles virus to secondary contacts .
Clustering of measles in both space and time has been identified at the country and regional levels in South Africa and Niger [6,22,23], but no studies have examined clustering in an urban setting of sub-Saharan Africa. Spatial-temporal clustering of measles was investigated during the 2010 outbreak in Lusaka, Zambia, and specifically whether HIV-infected children with measles were spatially clustered during the outbreak. Spatial-temporal clustering of measles cases among HIV-infected children was further explored during an endemic period (1998–2002) prior to national SIAs.
The University Teaching Hospital (UTH) is the largest public hospital in Lusaka, Zambia with a 415-bed Paediatrics and Child Health wing. Zambia has one of the highest HIV prevalence rates in sub-Saharan Africa and was prone to seasonal outbreaks of measles prior to the first national mass vaccination campaign in 2003 . In Zambia, 111 measles cases were reported in 2008 and only 26 cases in 2009. However, an outbreak resulting in 15736 reported cases occurred in 2010 [13,22]. Measles SIAs were conducted in 2007 and 2010.
1998-2002 endemic period
During the endemic period between 1998 and 2002, a prospective observational study of measles in HIV-infected and uninfected children hospitalized was conducted at the UTH . Clinical and demographic data were collected at enrollment and included date of hospitalization and the township in which the child resided. Plasma was tested for antibodies to HIV by enzyme immunoassay (Organon Tecknika, Boxtel, The Netherlands). Plasma levels of HIV RNA were quantified by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction assay (Amplicor HIV-1 Monitor v 1.5, Roche Molecular Systems, Branchburg, NJ) in children with antibodies to HIV. Children were classified as HIV-infected if HIV-1 RNA was detected in plasma. Measles virus infection was confirmed by detection of measles virus-specific IgM in plasma by EIA (Wampole Laboratories, Cranbury, NJ). Written informed consent was obtained from parents or guardians of study children. The study protocol was approved by institutional review boards at the Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health and the University Teaching Hospital, Lusaka, Zambia.
2010 measles outbreak
Clinical and epidemiological characteristics were retrospectively extracted from available patient records for all children younger than 16 years of age admitted to the UTH with a diagnosis of measles between January and December 2010. A detailed case assessment questionnaire was used to extract patient data, including date of hospitalization, measles vaccination history, township of residence and HIV infection status. For children older than 18 months of age, two independent enzyme immunoassays (an Abbott Determine rapid test kit [Alere Determine™ HIV-1/2 Ag/Ab Combo, Orgenics Ltd, Yavne Israel] followed by a confirmatory test with Genie II [Uni-Gold™ HIV, Trinity Biotech, Ireland] for positive rapid tests) were used to establish HIV infection. For infants younger than 18 months of age, HIV infection was confirmed by detection of HIV DNA by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (Amplicor HIV-1 Monitor v 1.5, Roche Molecular Systems, Branchburg, NJ). HIV seropositive children younger than 18 months of age for whom HIV DNA testing was not performed were considered HIV exposed. Children with unknown HIV infection status were excluded from spatial analyses (N = 88, 7.5%). Measles was diagnosed clinically and was confirmed by detection of IgM antibodies to measles virus by EIA (Wampole Laboratories, Cranbury, NJ). Date of hospitalization was used as a proxy for date of illness. Ethical approval was obtained by the University of Zambia (UNZA) Research Ethics Committee. The authors assert that all procedures contributing to this work comply with the ethical standards of the relevant national and institutional committees on human experimentation and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1975, as revised in 2008.
Hospitalized children with clinical or laboratory confirmed measles, known HIV infection or seropositive status, and who resided within Lusaka were included in the spatial analysis. An ArcGIS map of the townships of Lusaka was obtained from the Central Office of Statistics, Lusaka, Zambia for 2000 and for 2010. For 2010, incidence was calculated as the number of measles virus-infected children per township divided by the total population for that township obtained from the Central Statistics Office on the assumption that few measles cases occurred in adults. Cases were reported per day but were aggregated to the weekly level for analysis. A map was created showing the population density of Lusaka townships as persons per square kilometer. Three separate space-time cluster detection analyses were performed. The first compared HIV-infected to HIV-uninfected children to measure clustering of measles cases among HIV-infected children. This was conducted for both the 1998–2002 endemic and 2010 epidemic periods. The third space-time cluster detection analysis was conducted using all reported measles cases (independent of HIV infection status) to describe spatial clustering of measles cases during the 2010 epidemic period.
Case and control files, consisting of a unique identification number for the township of each child and the date of hospitalization, were constructed for HIV-infected (cases) and uninfected (controls) children hospitalized with measles. Children in whom HIV infection was not laboratory-confirmed were considered uninfected. The space-time cluster detection analyses were performed using SaTScan version 5.1 . SaTScan is a method for spatial, temporal and space-time cluster detection analysis that has been used in a wide variety of applications [9,26,27]. For the current application, case and control information were aggregated to the spatial township level and clusters were sought using a 7-day temporal scale. The expected number of cases was based on the distribution of all hospitalized measles cases. Statistical significance for identified clusters was based on Monte Carlo simulation using the Bernoulli probability model option in SaTScan, which is most appropriate for case–control data, adjusting for township population density . Significance for the 2010 outbreak analyses employed a permutation scheme within SaTScan as temporal changes in township population would be negligible over the one-year time frame [25,28].
1998-2002 endemic period
For the endemic period between January 1998 and January 2002, 1323 hospitalized children with suspected measles were enrolled. Of these, 1129 (85%) children were laboratory-confirmed to have measles virus infection and resided within one of 68 townships in Lusaka. Of the confirmed cases, 514 (46%) were male and the median age was 14 months (IQR = 9, 37), with a minimum of 2 and maximum 215 months (15.5 years). Only 209 (19%) had a history of measles vaccination, with 357 (32%) of unknown vaccination status. HIV-infection was confirmed in 164 children (15%) (Table 1). Temporal variation in the number of children studied was apparent in the time-series (Figure 1), reflecting the seasonality of measles virus transmission in Zambia prior to the SIA in 2003.
The space-time analysis detected a statistically significant cluster of six contiguous townships with a combined ratio of observed to expected number of measles cases in HIV-infected children of 6.4 (P = 0.03). This cluster of measles cases among HIV-infected children occurred between June 9, 1999 and November 2, 1999, a period of low transmission during which a subnational SIA was conducted in Lusaka (August 1999). During the identified cluster, 84 children with confirmed measles were hospitalized at UTH and enrolled, 17 of whom were HIV-infected (20%). Within the townships forming the spatial cluster, nine children with confirmed measles were enrolled during the interval from May to November 1999, seven of whom were HIV-infected (Figure 2). In contrast, thirteen children residing within the identified cluster were enrolled six months earlier but only two were HIV-infected, and twenty-nine children residing within the identified cluster were enrolled six months later but only three were HIV-infected (Figure 2). Thus, a higher than expected proportion of measles cases occurred among HIV-infected children in the cluster.
2010 measles outbreak
Between January and December 2010, 1614 hospitalized children with clinical measles were admitted to the UTH. Medical records were available and abstracted for 1331 children (82%). Of these, 1134 (85%) were laboratory confirmed and resided within one of 77 townships in Lusaka. Of the confirmed cases, 588 (52%) were male and the median age was 23.9 months (interquartile range = (7, 29), with a minimum of 0.75 and maximum of 175 months (15 years). Only 221 (20%) had a history of measles vaccination, with 286 (25%) of unknown measles vaccination status. One hundred children (9%) were classified as HIV-exposed and 41 (4%) as HIV-infected (Table 1). The highest number of hospitalized measles cases occurred in June and July 2010 (Figure 3).
The spatial distribution of the incidence of measles cases per 100000 persons in 2010 resembled the spatial pattern of population density: townships with higher population density had a higher overall reported incidence of measles in 2010 (Figure 4). No statistically significant clusters of measles cases were identified among HIV-infected or exposed children. However, three statistically significant and temporally distinct clusters of measles cases were identified using the space-time permutation, in April (P < 0.0001), August (P = 0.002) and October (P = 0.01) in three different geographical sections of the city (Figure 5). There were no significant differences between the three spatial-temporal clusters with regards to age, sex, HIV infection status or measles vaccination status among children with measles (Table 2).
Measles cases were spatially and temporally clustered during a large outbreak in Lusaka, Zambia in 2010, reflecting an evolving epidemic of local transmission foci and suggesting the potential to intervene through targeted vaccination efforts. Clustering of measles cases among HIV-infected children was identified prior to the introduction of intensive measles control efforts and during a period between seasonal peaks in measles incidence, suggesting susceptible HIV-infected children could contribute to measles virus transmission during inter-epidemic periods. Densely populated urban centers may pose an obstacle to measles control and elimination because the high levels of population immunity necessary to interrupt measles virus transmission are difficult to achieve . Mathematical models of meta-populations, accounting for local communities or patches, further confirm that heterogeneities in immunity can lead to increased rates of infection among susceptible individuals .
HIV infection is unlikely to be randomly distributed within urban communities, but rather concentrated in high-risk populations. In these urban pockets, HIV-infected children may remain susceptible to measles despite vaccination and antiretroviral therapy, facilitating measles virus transmission . HIV-infected children may contribute to measles virus transmission in urban settings with high HIV prevalence particularly during inter-epidemic periods when the number of susceptible children is depleted. No published studies have examined measles clustering among HIV-infected persons in sub-Saharan Africa.
There are several limitations to this study. The first is the bias of using hospitalized cases. The use of hospital-based data may not be representative as not all children with measles residing in Lusaka were likely hospitalized at the UTH during either study period. A mathematical model was used previously to estimate the probability of hospitalization for measles in Lusaka, Zambia, which was 6% for children younger than 1 year of age and 1.2% for persons older than 5 years of age . Although some cases may have been referred to smaller health centers, UTH is the largest public hospital in Lusaka and likely received most of the cases requiring hospitalization. Nevertheless, we believe these biases in the study population were unlikely to result in the space-time clustering of measles cases among HIV-infected children. The second is the small proportion of cases with confirmed HIV infection in 2010. This may be because HIV infection in 2010 was established from medical records. However, the University Teaching Hospital Pediatrics and Child Health wing has a well-established opt-out, routine HIV testing service  for all hospitalized children. The observed small proportion of confirmed HIV-infected children with measles in 2010 could be a reflection of the declining incidence of HIV infection resulting from the programs to prevent mother-to-child transmission introduced over the past decade in Lusaka [31,32]. The spatial point pattern based on the geolocation of each child’s residence could not be analyzed as only the township was recorded, with loss of spatial accuracy. Lastly, to calculate incidence we used the total population per township as the denominator and not the total number of children. If the proportion of children within each township varied, this heterogeneity may bias our rates. As a consequence of the case–control study design, as well as no data on the number of HIV-infected children within each township, we were not able to measure the incidence of measles in HIV-infected and uninfected children.
Additional data from outbreak investigations would help assess the magnitude of clustering and the distribution of measles clustering in cases not identified at UTH. Mapped spatial data of HIV and measles incidence at the township level would be useful to further quantify the degree of clustering of measles.
We demonstrated space-time clustering of measles cases during an outbreak in a densely populated urban center in sub-Saharan Africa and identified a cluster of HIV co-infected children during an earlier endemic period. Prediction and early identification of spatial clusters of measles outbreaks will be critical to achieving measles elimination and HIV infection may contribute to spatial clustering of measles cases in some epidemiological settings.
World Health Organization. WHO/UNICEF joint annual measles report 2010: strengthening immunization services through measles control. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization/Initiative on Measles and Rubella; 2010.
Simons E, Ferrari M, Fricks J, Wannemuehler K, Anand A, Burton A, et al. Assessment of the 2010 global measles mortality reduction goal: results from a model of surveillance data. Lancet. 2012;379:2173–8.
World Health Organization. Global measles and rubella strategic plan: 2012–2020. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2012.
Lowther S, Curriero F, Kalish B, Shields T, Monze M, Moss W. Population immunity to measles virus and the effect of HIV-1 infection after a mass measles vaccination campaign in Lusaka, Zambia: a cross sectional survey. Lancet. 2009;373:1025–32.
Orenstein W, Strebel P, Papana M, Sutter R, Bellini W, Cochi S. Measles eradication: is It in our future? Am J Public Health. 2000;90:1521–5.
Sartorius B, Cohen C, Chirwa T, Ntshoe G, Puren A, Hofman K. Identifying high risk areas for sporadic measles outbreaks: Lessons from South Africa. Bull World Health Organ. 2013;91:174–83.
Clarke K, McLafferty S, Tempalski B. On epidemiology and geographic information systems: a review and discussion of future directions. Emerg Infect Dis. 1996;2:85–93.
Kitron U. Landscape ecology and epidemiology of vector-borne diseases: tools for spatial analysis. J Med Entomol. 1998;35:435–45.
Jennings J, Curriero F, Celentano D, Ellen J. Geographic identification of high gonorrhea transmission areas in Baltimore, Maryland. Am J Epidemiol. 2005;161:73–80.
Ferrari M, Djibo A, Grais R, Bharti N, Grenfell B, Bjornstad O. Rural–urban gradient in seasonal forcing of measles transmission in Niger. Proc Biol Sci. 2010;277:2775–82.
MMWR. Progress toward global measles control and elimination, 1990–1996. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1997;46:893–7.
Moss W, Strebel P. Biological feasibility of measles eradication. J Infect Dis. 2011;204:S47–53.
Moss W, Griffin D. Measles. Lancet. 2012;379:153–64.
Scott S, Mossong J, Moss W, Cutts F, Kasolo F, Sinkala M, et al. Estimating the force of measles virus infection from hospitalized cases in Lusaka, Zambia. Vaccine. 2004;23:732–8.
Scott S, Mossong J, Moss W, Cutts F, Cousens S. Predicting impact of the HIV-1 epidemic on measles in developing countries: results from a dynamic age-structured model. Int J Epidemiol. 2008;37:356–67.
Lepage P, Dabis F, Msellati P, Mukamabano B, Goethem C, Perre P. Safety and immunogenicity of High-Dose Edmonston-Zagreb measles vaccine in children with HIV-1 infection: a cohort study in Kigali, Rwanda. Am J Dis Child. 1992;146:550–5.
Embree J, Datta P, Stackiw W, Sekla L, Braddick M, Kreiss J, et al. Increased risk of early measles in infants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1-seropositive mothers. J Infect Dis. 1992;165:262–7.
Moss W, Cutts F, Griffin D. Implications of the human immunodeficiency virus epidemic for control and eradication of measles. Clin Infect Dis. 1999;29:106–12.
Rainwater-Lovett K, Nkamba H, Mubiana-Mbewe M, Bolton-Moore C, Moss W. Changes in measles serostatus among HIV-infected Zambian children initiating antiretroviral therapy before and after the 2010 measles outbreak and supplemental immunization activities. J Infect Dis. 2013;208:1747–55.
CDC. Measles in HIV-infected children, United States: recommendations of the advisory committee on immunization practices (ACIP). In: Center for Disease Control and Prevention, editor. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. Atlanta, GA: Center for Disease Control and Prevention; 1988.
Permar S, Moss W, Ryon J, Monze M, Cutts F, Quinn T, et al. Prolonged measles virus shedding in human immunodeficiency virus-infected children, detected by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. J Infect Dis. 2001;183:532–8.
World Health Organization. Measles outbreaks and progress towards meeting measles pre-elimination goals: WHO African region. 2009–2010. In: World Health Organization, editor. Weekly Epidemiologic Record, vol. 86. 2011. p. 129–36.
Bharti N, Djibo A, Ferrari M, Grais R, Tatem A, McCabe C, et al. Measles hotspots and epidemiological connectivity. Epidemiol Infect. 2010;138:1308–16.
Moss W, Monze M, Ryon J, Quinn T, Griffin D, Cutts F. Prospective study of measles in hospitalized, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)- infected And HIV-uninfected children in Zambia. Clin Infect Dis. 2002;35:189–96.
Kulldorff M, I IMS. SaTScan ™ v8.0: software for the spatial and Space-time scan statistics;2009.
Wheeler D. A comparison of spatial clustering and cluster detection techniques for childhood leukemia incidence in Ohio, 1996–2003. Int J Health Geogr. 2007;6:13.
Klassen A, Curriero F, Kulldorff M, Alberg A, Platz E, Neloms S. Missing stage and grade in Maryland prostate cancer surveillance data, 1992–1997. Am J Prev Med. 2006;30:S77–87.
Kulldorf M, Heffernan R, Hartman J, Assuncao R, Mostashari F. A space-time permutation scan statistic for the early detection of disease outbreaks. PLoS Med. 2005;2:216–24.
Glass K, Kappey K, Grenfell B. The effect of heterogeneity in measles vaccination on population immunity. Epidemiol Infect. 2004;132:675–83.
Kankasa C, Carter R, Briggs N, Bulterys M, Chama E, Cooper E, et al. Routine offering of HIV testing to hospitalized pediatric patients at university teaching hospital, Lusaka, Zambia: acceptability and feasibility. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2009;51:202–8.
Stringer E, Chintu N, Levy J, Sinkala M, Chi B, Muyanga J, et al. Declining HIV prevalence among young pregnant women in Lusaka, Zambia. Bull World Health Organ. 2008;86:697–702.
Mahy M, Garcia-Calleja J, Marsh K. Trends in HIV prevalence among young people in generalised epidemics: implications for monitoring the HIV epidemic. Sex Transm Infect. 2012;88:i65–75.
Mr. Jailos Lubinda for ArcGIS assistance and acquisition of shapefiles.
Ms. Jane Zuba (SMUTH-MRU Office Research Assistant) for data entry and cleaning.
Ms. Mmamulatelo Sarah Siame and Ms. Muchabona Manyara for assisting with the data extraction from patients’ records.
Mrs. Sitwala for retrieving patient records and assisting with data extraction from patients’ records.
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
JP participated in the conception of the analysis plan, carried out statistical analyses, and drafted the manuscript. JC participated in design of the study, managed lab/data collection, assisted with interpretation of data, and revision of the manuscript. GCB assisted with data collection, data entry and data cleaning. SM managed and carried out the lab testing for measles, assisted with the conception of the 2010 study, and assisted with data collection. TS assisted with spatial mapping and geocoding of townships. FCC participated in the conception of the analysis plan and assisted with statistical analyses and revision of the manuscript. WJM participated in conception of the study and manuscript, participated in the conception of the analysis plan and revision of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.